Illustrative image – not actual.
A Supreme Court-appointed panel has backed the development of five hydroelectric projects (HEPs) on the Ganga river and its tributaries in Uttarakhand, amidst opposition from the Ministry of Environment and Forest (MoEF) and the Jal Shakti Ministry, which cited risks related to ecological impacts and the seismic or landslide-prone nature of the region.
The court's involvement began in 2013 following the catastrophic Kedarnath floods that claimed over 5,000 lives. Initially, the Supreme Court imposed a moratorium on new HEPs and directed the MoEF to assess their impacts. Over the years, three committees examined the projects, with findings varying from significant ecological risks to recommendations for limited approvals. The first committee, led by Ravi Chopra in 2014, advised against 24 projects, citing disaster risks.
A second panel under IIT-Kanpur’s Vinod Tare in 2015 flagged severe ecological concerns for six proposed HEPs. In 2020, a third committee led by B P Das recommended approval for 28 projects. However, the Central government permitted only seven projects in 2021, a decision influenced by deliberations in the Prime Minister’s Office.
A high-level committee headed by Cabinet Secretary T V Somanathan revisited the B P Das report. On 08 November, this panel recommended greenlighting five projects: Bowala Nandprayag (300 MW on the Alaknanda River), Devasri (252 MW on the Pinder River), Bhyundar Ganga (24.3 MW), Jhalakoti (12.5 MW), and Urgam-II (7.5 MW). The panel’s recommendations reflect a cautious approach, endorsing a limited number of projects after weighing the risks and benefits.
