Illustrative image – not actual.National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) is planning to invite fresh financial bids from all the five shortlisted bidders for developing the Rs.673 crore six-lane Jaipur-Kishangarh highway project on NH-8 in Rajasthan.
It may be recalled that the project has been under bidding for more than five years.
The decision to invite fresh bids for finalising the project comes after the lone bid submitted jointly by Larsen & Toubro (L&T) and Joannou & Paraskevaides (Overseas) Ltd (J&P) of Cyprus was found to be a conditional bid, which had set terms that there deviations from the tender documents.
The other bidders in the fray included Reliance Industries Ltd, Bin Hafeez (West Asia) and Group 5 (South Africa). L&T and J&P, which were pre-qualified in their individual capacities, had submitted a price bid jointly to share the risks associated with the project, particularly on traffic flows. But the bid had sought a change in the existing arrangement prescribed by the government for granting the upfront capital grant, the main bidding criteria which determines the award of the highway project.
As per the guidelines for disbursing the capital grant amount to private operators for boosting the viability of highway projects, 25 per cent of the grant would be given during the construction phase and 15 per cent during the maintenance stage of the project. In the tender documents, NHAI has limited its capital grant liability to a maximum of Rs.244 crore, out of which 25 per cent would be paid to the successful bidder during the construction phase and the remaining 15 per cent during the maintenance period of the project depending upon the amount of capital grant quoted by the bidder.
However, the bid submitted by the L&T-J&P combine wanted the capital grant to be given in one go without breaking it up into two parts. The combine had told the NHAI that it needed the capital grant money more for the construction of the highway and would manage the maintenance portion through collection of tolls. If the capital grant element is given in two parts, its financial stream would be affected and it would therefore not be interested in taking up the project.
However, if the government accepts the condition put forward by the combine, it may reportedly lead to litigation on the grounds that this scenario was not known to the other shortlisted bidders when the financial bids were called by NHAI in August 2000. NHAI had referred the issue to the Ministry of Road Transport & Highways, which asked NHAI to call for fresh price bids from all the shortlisted bidders so as to provide a level playing field to all.
