Illustrative image – not actual.Mumbai Urban Transport Project (II): A Profile
(Updated as of 31 March 2001)
Introduction
The
Mumbai Urban Transport Project (II) is a Rs.7,700 crore multi-modal project
aimed at streamlining and decongesting the existing transport system in the metropolitan
city of Mumbai through improved rail and road services. The project, currently
under implementation, is being funded largely through financial assistance from
the World Bank (See Role of World Bank in MUTP II).
The project has a gestation period of around seven years. MUTP-II, also known
simply as MUTP, is being implemented by the Mumbai Metropolitan Region
Development Authority (MMRDA) in concert with other entities such as Mumbai
Rail Vikas Corporation (MRVC), Maharashtra State Road Development Corporation
(MSRDC), Brihanmumbai Electricity Supply & Transport (BEST), Brihanmumbai
Municipal Corporation (BMC) and the Mumbai Traffic Police Department, among
others.
Background
The
genesis of MUTP II can be traced to the formation of the Mumbai Metropolitan
Region Development Authority (MMRDA) in January 1975. This entity was formed
with a view to developing the Mumbai Metropolitan Region comprising the capital
city of Mumbai and the fast-developing hinterland.
MMRDA
embarked upon its first project, Mumbai Urban Transport Project (MUTP) – I, in
1976. This project, then costing Rs.39 crore, was completed in 1983. The
project’s focus area was on improving the road transport facilities. The main
achievements of MUTP – I have been:
- Construction of five
flyovers near high-traffic areas in Mumbai
- Construction of
pedestrian bridges and underpasses at important junctions
- Procurement of over
700 buses for BEST
- Installation of
microprocessor-based traffic signals at 77 major road junctions
In 1988, the State
government of Maharashtra approached the World Bank for financial assistance
for an ambitious project to improve the transport facilities – mainly road
transport and traffic control systems – in Mumbai and suburban areas. Thus was
conceived the Mumbai Urban Transport Project (MUTP) – II.
The
World Bank was in broad agreement with the Government of Maharashtra, but
insisted that the project assume the form of a combined railway and roadway
project; the insistence stemming from the growing importance of railway
transport in Mumbai and suburban areas. (See Railway
Traffic in Mumbai)
Soliciting
participation from the Indian Railways did not come about easily. It took about
five years (till around 1993) for the Indian Railways to even commit tentative
participation. This commitment remained largely on paper till 1997; the
Railways always citing paucity of funds as a deterrent. It was only in 1998
that the Indian Railways entered into an in-principle agreement with the
Government of Maharashtra to participate in the MUTP II on a 50:50 basis.
In
July 1999, the Mumbai Rail Vikas Corporation (MRVC) was incorporated as a 51:49
joint venture between the Indian Railways and the Government of Maharashtra,
with an equity capital of Rs.25 crore. (See box MRVC:
Origin & Objectives)
Meanwhile, in an
independent development, Maharashtra State Road Development Corporation (MSRDC)
was incorporated as a limited company, fully owned by the government of
Maharashtra, on 2 August 1996.The main objective of MSRDC is to accelerate the
development of road transport facilities in the State.
With
the formation of MSRDC and MRVC, the nature of MUTP II changed considerably
from that of its forerunner MUTP I. Unlike its predecessor, MUTP II is not
solely a responsibility of MMRDA but involves a wider participation of
government agencies. MUTP II is also much larger in scope entailing railway
projects and the concomitant rehabilitation and resettlement of
project-affected persons.
Project Scope
The MUTP II project can be
broadly divided into three parts -- Suburban Railway Component, Road and
Traffic Management Component, and Rehabilitation and Resettlement of
project-affected persons (PAPs). The entire project has been divided into two
phases of which the first phase is under implementation. Even here, it is the
rehabilitation and restoration of project-affected persons that is uppermost in
the implementation schedule. The scope of the second phase has not been clearly
defined since this would be considered only after Phase I is successfully
implemented. Moreover, as of now, there exists no firm World Bank commitment
for Phase II of the project. Phase I is targeted for completion by 2006.
Project Cost
The
cost of the MUTP II is an estimated Rs.7,700 crore, at current prices. Table 1
gives the approximate break-up of the total cost. (Please note that that the
cost of Phase II of the project is indicative).
|
Table 1: Project Cost of MUTP II |
|||
|
Component |
(Rs.crore) |
||
|
|
Phase I |
Phase II |
Total |
|
Suburban
Railway |
3,108 |
2,545 |
5,653 |
|
Road &
Traffic Management |
753 |
947 |
1,700 |
|
Rehabilitation
of PAPs* |
320 |
320 |
|
|
*Only
Railway Component has been considered |
|
||
Project Details
A. Road & Traffic Component
Projects
falling under the road and traffic component of the MUTP II are being implemented
by a variety of agencies such as MSRDC, BEST and BMC. This component has a
total cost of around Rs.1,700 crore.
Phase
I of this component is currently underway at an estimated outlay of Rs.753
crore. The main projects encompassed by this phase are given in Table 2.
|
Table 2: Road & Traffic
Component of MUTP II |
|
|
(Phase I only)* |
|
|
Project
Segment |
Cost |
|
|
(Rs.crore) |
|
Jogeshwari-Vikhroli
Link Road |
102 |
|
Santacruz-Chembur
Link Road |
154 |
|
ROB at
Jogeshwari (South) |
65 |
|
ROB at
Jogeshwari (North) |
44 |
|
ROB at
Vikhroli |
28 |
|
Buses |
120 |
|
Pedestrian
Subways and Bridges |
30 |
|
Area
Traffic Control |
65 |
|
Station
Area Traffic Improvement |
30 |
|
Other
Traffic Management Schemes |
35 |
|
Dadar-Mahim
One-Way System |
5 |
|
Air
Quality Monitoring System |
25 |
|
Technical
Assistance, Training, etc. |
50 |
|
Total |
753 |
|
*Complete
details of Phase II are not available |
|
Development
of roads and bridges is the main aspect of this component, taking up Rs.423 crore
or 56 per cent of the total cost.
Another
Rs.120 crore (or 16 per cent of the total cost) has been earmarked for
procurement of buses. This project segment falls under the purview of the BEST.
The
remaining 28 per cent of the project cost would be spent mainly towards traffic
control systems.
The
road and traffic component also entails the rehabilitation and resettlement of
over 4,500 families, which would be affected by the first five project segments
given in Table 2. The cost of rehabilitation has been included in the
respective project segment cost.
B. Railway Component
Railways-related
projects form the backbone of the MUTP II and are being implemented by Mumbai
Rail Vikas Corporation. Out of the total outlay of Phase I, a sum of Rs.3,108
crore (or nearly 75 per cent) has been earmarked for this component. Table 3
gives the fourteen project segments that constitute the Railway component of
MUTP II.
Optimization
of the Western and Central Railways and the Harbour Line is the most
significant facet of the Railway component of MUTP II, accounting for 35 per
cent of the total cost. Projects for the optimization of the Western and
Central Railway are described below.
Western Railway
Scope: This project would begin with the removal of all
level crossings between Borivili and Virar. A semi-terminus at Goregaon and a
new railway station at Oshiwara has also been envisaged. Overall improvement in
the Western Railway system has been targeted through lengthening of platforms,
installation of new signaling equipment, increase in power supply and
procurement of additional rakes.
Benefit: The project will permit the maximum feasible 18
trains per hour on the local line between Churchgate and Borivili. Similar
improvement would be seen in the case of trains running on the through lines
between Churchgate and Virar. There would be an expected 35 per cent increase
in the train kilometers (i.e. number of trains multiplied by distance
travelled), due to installation of new rakes.
Status: This project is under execution.
|
Table 3: Railway Component of MUTP
II |
||||
|
(Phase I and II) |
||||
|
(Rs.crore) |
||||
|
Project
Segment |
Project Cost* |
World Bank |
||
|
|
Phase I |
Phase II |
Total |
Assistance |
|
5th Line
between Santacruz & Borivili |
158 |
--- |
158 |
49 |
|
Extra pair
of lines between Kurla & Thane |
399 |
--- |
399 |
172 |
|
Borivili-Bhayandar
(Additional Pair of Lines) |
229 |
--- |
229 |
81 |
|
Bhayandar-Virar
(Additional Pair of Lines) |
348 |
--- |
348 |
78 |
|
Optimisation
of Western Railway** |
365 |
463 |
828 |
556 |
|
Optimisation
of Central Railway** |
444 |
415 |
859 |
181 |
|
Optimisation
of Harbour Line |
259 |
32 |
291 |
150 |
|
5th Line
(Kurla - Dadar - CSTM) |
--- |
229 |
229 |
36 |
|
6th Line
between Borivili & Santacruz |
--- |
210 |
210 |
45 |
|
East-West
Bandra Kurla Link |
--- |
975 |
975 |
902 |
|
DC - AC
Conversion |
400 |
201 |
601 |
313 |
|
EMU
Manufacture |
450 |
--- |
450 |
375 |
|
Track
Machines |
12 |
20 |
32 |
32 |
|
Technical
Assistance |
44 |
--- |
44 |
44 |
|
Total |
3,108 |
2,545 |
5,653 |
3,014 |
|
*Project cost is inclusive of World
Bank assistance |
|
|
|
|
|
**Includes procurement of 12-Coach
Rakes |
|
|
|
|
Central
Railway
Scope:
The project scope entails the
reconditioning of tracks on the Central Railway line. The two yards at CST and
Kalyan would also be re-modelled. Besides, new signaling equipment would be
installed in the local corridor and the level crossing at Vikhroli would be
removed. Power supply to the Central Railway line would also be augmented.
Benefit: The optimization would permit 16 trains
(with nine rakes) per hour on the local line and 12 trains (with 12 rakes) per
hour on the through line in the CST-Kalyan section.
Status: The project is under implementation.
![]()
Out
of the total 14 projects of the Railway component of MUTP II, eight projects
were under implementation, as of March 2001. The largest railway line project
envisaged in the Railway component is the East-West Bandra-Kurla Link project.
The project, to be taken up in Phase II of MUTP II, would cost around Rs.975
crore. The World Bank would be funding this project to the extent of Rs.902
crore, or 93 per cent.
Besides offering a direct
link between the Central and Western Railway lines, the project would also
provide additional facilities. Presently, a journey from Bandra to Kurla
entails change of route at Dadar. The new link would obviate this change of
route and would help alleviate the present congestion at Dadar. This project
would also provide a direct rail link to the fast-developing Bandra-Kurla
complex. Besides, a direct rail link between Andheri and Panvel has also been
envisaged.
Rehabilitation &
Resettlement of Project Affected People
As
mentioned earlier, the rehabilitation and resettlement of project affected
people (PAPs) forms an integral part of the MUTP II.
|
Table 4: Rehabilitation under MUTP
II |
|||
|
(As on 23 January 2001) |
|||
|
Project |
Number of PAPs Rehabilitated |
||
|
|
Permanent |
Transit |
Total |
|
|
Tenements |
Tenements |
|
|
Optimisation
of Harbour Line |
1,521 |
2,319 |
3,840 |
|
Kurla-Thane
New Lines |
254 |
935 |
1,189 |
|
Santacruz-Borivli
New Line |
103 |
17 |
120 |
|
Total |
1,878 |
3,271 |
5,149 |
This
aspect assumes significance not due to its project cost but due to the fact
that World Bank assistance is governed by how ably this social project is
handled.
Of
the two major components of the MUTP II, it is the Railway component that
entails most of the rehabilitation and resettlement of persons. This is
particularly true of projects that envisage optimizing of the Central, Harbour
and Western Railway Lines. The numberof families that would be affected by the
MUTP II is estimated at 19,128. Of this 4,649 families would be affected by the
road and traffic component, while a large chunk of 14,479 families would face
dislocation by Railways-related projects.
The
work of clearing hutments from areas adjoining railway tracks commenced even
before the formation of MRVC. At the time of inaugurating the MRVC (July 1999)
the Union Minister for Railways handed over 800 transit tenements to PAPs.
During
January 2001, MMRDA handed over 1,441 permanent tenements to an equal number of
project affected families. At the same time, work for constructing 3,600
transit tenements was initiated. It was estimated that by the end of March
2001, rehabilitation of an additional 5,000 PAPs would be completed.
MRVC: Origin & Objectives
Maharashtra
Rail Vikas Corporation (MRVC) is the culmination of the formal agreement
between the Indian Railways (IR) and the Government of Mahrashtra (GoM) to
implement the railway component of the MUTP II. MRVC can be construed as a
by-product of World Bank’s insistence. The inclusion of railway projects under
the proposed MUTP and the formation of a corporate entity to implement the same
were the prime pre-conditions for receiving World Bank assistance when the
Government of Maharashtra first approached the World Bank in 1988.
MRVC
was incorporated on 12 July 1999, after much deliberation between the GoM and
the IR. It was often feared that MRVC would never see the light of the day
given the inertia of the IR in committing to a joint venture. Had the IR
responded to the GoM’s proposal when the World Bank first laid out its
pre-condition, MRVC would have been formed by around 1990. Even after having
agreed to a joint venture in 1993, it took six more years for MRVC to take
form. With the result, MUTP II has suffered inestimable cost overruns during
this period of hibernation from 1993 to 1999.
MRVC
is a 51:49 joint venture between the IR and GoM. It has an equity capital of
Rs.25 crore. MRVC was inaugurated on 29 April 2000 at the hands of Ms Mamta
Banerjee, the then Union Minster for Railways.
MRVC
is much more than a special purpose vehicle to implement the railway component
of MUTP II, it has, among others, a big task of ultimately unifying the
operations of Western Railway and Central Railway -- the two prime agencies
currently managing the suburban railway network in Mumbai.
The
main objectives of the MRVC are:
·
Developing and co-ordinating plans for rail
projects included under the MUTP II and other such planned investments for
Mumbai’s rail services.
·
Ensuring improvement of track drainage and removing
encroachments from the right of way of the Railways.
·
Undertaking rehabilitation and resettlement of
persons affected by the MUTP II and subsequent projects.
·
Undertaking commercial development of Railway land
and airspace.
It may
be mentioned that the revenue earned through commercial use of railway land and
airspace would part-finance the Railway component of MUTP II and subsequent
projects. As per the MoU between the IR and GoM, the revenue earned by the
exploitation of Railway land and airspace would be shared equally between the
IR, GoM and MRVC. The GoM would spend its share of revenue on development of
railway projects in Maharashtra, whereas the IR would be free to deploy its
revenue share as per its discretion.
Role of World Bank in MUTP II
The
role of World Bank as a funding agency is critical to MUTP II. World Bank,
subject to conditions, has agreed to finance up to 70 per cent of the total
cost of the project. The fructification of MUTP II therefore hinges on the
fulfilling of World Bank conditions.
The
first pre-condition was imposed by the World Bank when the GoM first approached
the agency with the ambitious MUTP, in 1988. The World Bank insisted that the
project be blended with a significant portion of railway projects. It further
demanded that a separate entity be set up for overseeing these projects. It was
this pre-requisite that ultimately saw the birth of MVRC. World Bank also
maintained that funding would be contingent on the removal of encroachments
lying in the right of way of the Railways, and the rehabilitation and
resettlement of persons so affected. This rehabilitation is expected to cost
Rs.320 crore, 90 per cent of which would be funded by World Bank. Resettlement
of PAPs is reportedly progressing satisfactorily, boding well for the future of
MUTP II.
During
his visit to India in November 2000, World Bank President, Mr James Wolfensohn,
sanctioned Rs.2,000 crore towards the MUTP II. The disbursement is expected to
be made by May 2001. Assistance is expected to materialize in tranches, albeit
subject to a continual adhering to WB conditions.
Railway
traffic in Mumbai
Mumbai
Rail Vikas Corporation (MVRC) has estimated that the Mumbai suburban railway has
the highest density amongst similar large-volume suburban services in the
world. It is learnt that the Mumbai suburban railway, with a total route length
of 302 km, carries around 6.1 million passengers per day. This translates to a
passenger density of over 20,000 persons per km per day. The table alongside
shows comparable density of some other important cities in the world
|
Passenger Density in Major Suburban
Railways |
|||
|
City |
Passengers |
Route |
Passenger |
|
|
per day |
Length |
Density |
|
|
(million) |
(kms) |
('000/km/day) |
|
Mumbai |
6.10 |
302 |
20.20 |
|
Tokyo |
18.90 |
1,272 |
14.86 |
|
Seoul |
2.20 |
171 |
12.87 |
|
Buenos
Aires |
2.10 |
819 |
2.56 |
|
Rio de
Janeiro |
0.17 |
264 |
0.64 |
|
Values
estimated by MRVC |
|
|
|
