Iron ore mine lease: CMT seeks review of decisionIllustrative image – not actual.

The Central Mines Tribunal (CMT) has asked the Orissa government to review its decision (taken on 10 July 2003) to cancel the iron ore mining lease granted to Tata Iron & Steel and Larsen & Toubro (L&T) at Makarnacha in the Keonjhar district of the state, and to examine the issue afresh along with applications for mining licences made by other applicants.

 

Orissa Chief Minister, Mr Naveen Patnaik had announced in Bhubaneshwar on July 10 that the government had recommended cancellation of allotment of iron ore mines at Makarnacha to L&T and Tisco, in view of no progress made by the proposed projects of these companies.

 

The central government had granted the mine lease under a memorandum of understanding (MoU) with the Orissa government in 1995 to feed Tisco’s proposed steel plant project at Gopalpur.

 

Tisco and L&T had filed appeals against the Orissa decision. The tribunal had then granted a stay on the cancellation order. The tribunal thereafter issued another directive, suggesting review of the cancellation.

 

The Orissa mines minister A U Singhdeo had complained to the Union mines ministry that if the state government cancelled a mining lease, the Central Mines Tribunal should not grant stay on the cancellation without consulting the state. CMT thus suggested only a review.

 

Jindal Steel & Power has recently approached the Orissa government for mines to feed a proposed two million tonne capacity integrated steel plant at Deojhar in the Keonjhar district of Orissa.

 

The site was between Joda and Noamundi, two of Tata Steel’s iron ore mines. Jindal Steel has a mine at Kalta. In all, 10 proposals for mining licences worth Rs.44,000 crore have been filed with the Orissa government. Orissa cannot issue fresh mining leases unless the Union mines ministry cancelled the earlier ones.

 

The Orissa mines department has pointed out that the mining lease had been granted to Tisco on condition that failure to set up the plant at Gopalpur would lead to cancellation of the mining lease and its reissue to other investors committed to setting up a steel plant in Orissa. Tisco has dropped its plans for a steel plant at Gopalpur, in favour of a capacity expansion at its Jamshedpur Steel Complex in Jharkhand.

 

The Orissa government thereafter decided to cancel the mining lease. L&T’s application was also linked to Tisco’s Gopalpur project and therefore was recommended for cancellation as well.

 

Tisco maintained that it was Orissa government’s failure to upgrade Gopalpur port that aborted the steel plant project. Without Gopalpur being upgraded from a seasonal anchorage to an all weather port, a steel plant could not function there.

 

The Orissa government has cancelled its MoU for upgrading Gopalpur port in partnership with Gujarat-based Adnani Exports Limited (AEL) on July 2. AEL did not sign the concessions agreement by the March 2003 deadline for the transaction.

 

AEL prayed for extension of the MoU till September 2003 but the state government rejected this plea. A new tender for development of the port was likely to be issued soon.

 

Related Stories

 

Tata Steel capex plan to cost less (28-Jul-03)

Orissa government urges government to scrap mining lease (16-Jul-03)

Gopalpur Port project: MoU scrapped (3-Jul-03)

← All latest storiesBack to top →