18 January 2005
The private power policy of GOI has generated keen interest among the project developers and domestic and international financing community. We have over 90 proposals from the private sector for putting up power projects for a capacity of about 50,000 MW. Most of the present proposals with the GOI have evolved on the basis of negotiations for which Memorandum of Understandings (MOUs) have been signed by the States with the project promoters. This has sparked an intense debate in the media and in various other forums in relation to the selection of private power companies without the competitive bidding route.
In the initial phase of any private investment policy in case of the capital intensive infrastructure projects, the proposals from private sector can come up only through negotiations, more so in the case of private power projects, as there is no earlier experience in this area both for the investors as well as the government. Furthermore, the financial health of the State Electricity Boards (SEBs) would not have evoked the requisite confidence amongst the investors to participate in an open bid for the private power projects in the initial stages. The negotiated route was, therefore, the only feasible option to provide a fillip to the private power policy in its initial phase of implementation. However, the importance of a transparent competitive bidding procedure in assigning power projects to the private companies has very well been recognized by the government and it would now be the obvious choice after necessary experience has been gained by the government and the private sector.
The competitive bidding process needs considerable preparatory work before it could be successfully implemented. For the competitive bidding process to be successful, it is mandatory to evolve a well thought out plan by the States. Establishment of transparent bidding procedures and a set of preannounced criteria against which bids would be evaluated, would be essential for such an approach. In this regard, both the price and non-price factors for evaluating the bids will have to be carefully considered and selected. The non-price factors which would normally relate to the technical parameters of the project and the competence of the bidder would have to be precise, explicit and unambiguous. Lack of clarity and specifying broad and general criteria would lead to submission of significantly different proposals making the evaluation exercise an inept task. Evaluation of price bids would also require considerable preparatory effort particularly in applying net preset value techniques, comparative assessment of the foreign exchange implications of various offers, comparative sensitive analysis of specific risk factors etc. Expertise in these areas within the government can be developed only over a period of time.
Adoption of a bidding procedure would also imply a certain amount of readiness of the project as well (viz.finalisation of the feasibility report, availability of all clearances including environmental clearance and the project site - which are time consuming matters) and of course definite clarity about the yardstick/criteria which are to be used on the basis of which bids are to be evaluated.
The competitive bidding process is normally followed I two stages: (i) the RFQ (Request for Qualifications) stage and (ii) RFP (Request for Proposal) stage.
The RFQ stage establishes a threshold criteria in the four principal areas viz. Organisation, Financial Capability, Management Capability and Technical Capability so as to qualify for the subsequent RFP process only those parties which meet the stipulated criteria. The RFQ threshold criteria needs to be carefully framed to ensure that the selection at the RFP stage is done to a larger extent only on quantifiable price considerable, the other parameters having been eliminated in the RFQ stage.
The RFP process also needs considerable preparatory work. The design of RFP should broadly take into consideration factors such as engineering adequacies , acceptance of SEB operating requirements, pricing, plant availability, draft PPA and other agreements to be provided to the bidders, evaluation criteria, price caps, acceptable inflation indices and clear identification of GOI's, state government's, SEB's and bidders' responsibilities. These would have to be framed in an unambiguous manner to seek uniform information from the bidders in the prescribed formats to facilitate smooth evaluation.
Most of the project developers find competitive bidding to be a costly and time consuming exercise as preparation of Feasibility Reports etc., which have to necessarily precede bidding involve high costs. The developers are not prepared to commit themselves to such high investments in the project development phase. Establishment of a bidding procedure would thus imply preparation of a shelf of fully cleared projects both for generation and distribution as well as establishment of a set of a criteria for evaluation of bids received in response to invitation for bids for specific projects. This is obviously a time consuming process and would require significant effort on the part of the State Government and the SEBs.
