Illustrative image – not actual.As per information tabled in Parliament
in March 2001, Central public sector undertakings (CPSUs) were implementing 75
projects in the State of Maharashtra, as on 31 December 2000. The total cost of
these projects, at the time of latest government approval, was Rs.11,377.3
crore.
These projects prominently included
those of railways (29 projects), atomic energy and surface transport (both 14),
petroleum (seven) and coal (four).
Out of the 75 projects, cost overruns
were witnessed in 28 projects, or a little over one-third of the total. The
number of railway projects affected by cost overruns was the highest, at 20. In
other words, nearly 70 per cent of the railway projects in the State were beset
by cost overruns. Four projects in the surface transport sector (out of the
total 14) were similarly affected.
The cost of the 20 railway projects
afflicted by cost overruns, which was Rs.2290 crore at the time of latest
government approval, has now been estimated at Rs.3267.8 crore. This implied a
cost overrun of 42.7 per cent. In the case of surface transport projects, the
cost overrun has been estimated at 56.3 per cent.
The
total cost of the 28 projects suffering cost escalation was an estimated
Rs.6256.2 crore when last approved. The anticipated cost of these projects is
now Rs.13,200.1 crore – twice the original cost.
Projects
facing cost overrun had an untoward bearing on the overall investment programme
of CPSUs in Maharashtra. The total anticipated
cost of all the 75 projects underway in Maharashtra now stands nearly 60 per
cent higher than the original cost.
The situation regarding time overruns
was at little variance with that of cost overruns. Out of the total 75 CPSU
projects underway in Maharashtra as on 31 December 2000, time overruns dogged
32. These 32 projects also included some that were weighed down by both time
and cost overruns.
The extent of time overrun ranged from
an innocuous four months to an incredible 69 months (almost six years). Time
overruns were mainly noticed in railway and roadway projects and atomic power
projects being implemented by Nuclear Power Corporation of India at its Tarapur
Atomic Power Plant. Sixteen out of the 32 projects stymied by time overruns
were railway projects.
An isolated case of extreme time delay
was the modernization project of the Government Mint in Maharashtra. This
project has been delayed by a ludicrous nine years. The cost of the project has
nearly trebled to Rs.348.8 crore from the last-approved Rs.118.3 crore.
The average time delay (weighted by the
investment involved) worked out to around 39 months, or over three years.
Maharashtra can however derive some
solace from the fact that the investment blocked in by projects suffering time
overruns (at 25 per cent) is not very significant, at least compared to
corresponding all-India figures. (Based on information tabled in Parliament
in November 2000, it is learnt that nearly 44 per cent of the investment by
CPSUs is troubled with time overruns.)
