Illustrative image – not actual.The Comptroller & Auditor General of India has criticized National Highways Authority of India for inordinate delay in completing Phase I (Golden Quadrilateral) of the National Highways Development Programme.
In its reported tabled in Parliament, CAG said the NHAI completed only 1,846 km in terms of completed stretches of the target of 6,359 km by the scheduled date of June 2004.
The CAG report said that there was no corporate plan to implement such a large project and deficient planning and inefficient contract management by the design and project consultants led to underperformance in achieving the target. The adverse impact of the significant underperformance resulted in unrealized expected benefit of free flow of traffic on these routes.
Besides, NHAI also lost a chance to generate toll revenue of at least Rs.560 crore due to the delay in the completion of the highways. The road users also lost potential economy in vehicle operating cost of about Rs 4,300 crore over the period of delay, the report further stated.
NHAI was slow to introduce tolling on the completed portions of the road and lost about Rs.42 crore due to delayed notifications.
Stating that NHAI did not standardise its procedures and contract documents, the report said the inconsistencies and infirmities in the contract conditions led to contractual complications, overpayments and delay. Criticising the NHAI for not ensuring enforcement of contract provisions for quality assurance and project management, it said this led to execution of "sub-standard works in seven stretches test checked for quality of 32 stretches examined in audit".
NHAI took up contracts for 20 works valued at Rs.779 crore without detailed project reports (DPRs). There were also wide variations ranging from 12.26 per cent to 86.82 per cent between the awarded cost and executed cost in respect of nine stretches indicating deficiencies in DPRs.
The report assailed the NHAI for not standardising the length of stretches for award of contacts to facilitate cost comparison for ward and execution of work; nor did it devise any effective cost control mechanism as an alternative. This resulted in variation in cost per km of contiguous stretches from Rs.1.86 crore to Rs.4.20 crore per km.
The report suggested that NHAI strengthen its planning regime and follow-up mechanism with various agencies to avert bottlenecks such as land acquisition, tree cutting and shifting of utilities.
